Samsung Galaxy S24 UltravsGoogle Pixel 9 Pro XL
SETTLEDUpdated September 8, 2026
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra wins
Verdict
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra wins 2 of 5 categories — our overall pick
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra is the overall winner, 2 / 5 — battery is its standout. At USD 1,099, it's also the most affordable of this group.
- Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra takes Performance — led by performance score (1,900,000 pts).
- Too close to call between Google Pixel 9 Pro XL and Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra.
- Google Pixel 9 Pro XL takes Camera — led by selfie camera (42 MP).
- Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra takes Battery — led by charging speed (45 W).
- Too close to call between Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra and Google Pixel 9 Pro XL.
Scores follow our published methodology · v2026.09
In plain English
Choose Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra if you want…
- Choose Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra if you want a faster phone for apps and games — 1,900,000 pts vs 1,000,000 pts.
- Choose Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra if you want more room for photos and apps — 256 GB vs 128 GB.
- Choose Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra if you want a sharper screen — 505 ppi vs 486 ppi.
- Choose Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra if you want faster charging — 45 W vs 37 W.
Choose Google Pixel 9 Pro XL if you want…
- Choose Google Pixel 9 Pro XL if you want more apps open at once — 16 GB vs 12 GB.
- Choose Google Pixel 9 Pro XL if you want a screen you can read in sunlight — 3,000 nits vs 2,600 nits.
- Choose Google Pixel 9 Pro XL if you want sharper selfies — 42 MP vs 12 MP.
- Choose Google Pixel 9 Pro XL if you want better video quality — 97 pts vs 96 pts.
- Choose Google Pixel 9 Pro XL if you want a better camera — 150 pts vs 144 pts.
- Choose Google Pixel 9 Pro XL if you want longer battery life — 5,060 mAh vs 5,000 mAh.
At a glance
- Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra
- Google Pixel 9 Pro XL
Click a label to jump to that section ↓
Best price now
Full record
Every spec, side by side — winners get a check and a proportional bar. Ties share the badge.
Performance score
Approximate benchmark score of the chipset — higher is faster for apps, games and AI.
Chipset
The processor inside — shown for reference, never decides a winner.
RAM
More RAM keeps more apps alive in the background.
Storage
Base onboard storage for photos, apps and media.
Screen size
Diagonal screen size — bigger is better for media, smaller is easier to hold.
Pixel density
Sharpness of the screen — above ~400 ppi looks crisp.
Refresh rate
How smooth scrolling and motion feel. 120 Hz is the modern standard.
Peak brightness
Peak brightness in sunlight — higher stays readable outdoors.
Main camera
Resolution of the primary rear camera — photo quality is judged by the Camera quality score, not megapixels.
Selfie camera
Resolution of the front camera.
Telephoto
A dedicated zoom lens for distant subjects without quality loss.
Video score
Composite video rating — stabilisation, 4K/8K support and colour.
Camera score
Composite camera quality from independent testing — how good the photos actually are.
Battery
Battery capacity — higher generally lasts longer.
Charging speed
Wired charging speed — higher refills faster.
Wireless charging
Whether the phone charges wirelessly.
Price
Typical MSRP in US dollars — lower is better value.
Which one should you buy?
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra
Choose Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra if battery matters most — it wins the most categories overall. It costs USD 1,099, the lowest price in this group.
Google Pixel 9 Pro XL
Choose Google Pixel 9 Pro XL if camera matters most. It costs USD 1,099.
Pros & cons
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra
- 200 MP camera
- S Pen built in
- Bright display
- Heavy
- 45 W charging
- Sharp corners
Google Pixel 9 Pro XL
- Class-leading photos
- 5x telephoto
- 7 years of updates
- Tensor trails rivals
- 37 W charging
- Expensive