Redmi A3vsRealme P1 5G
SETTLEDUpdated September 8, 2026
Realme P1 5G wins
Verdict
Realme P1 5G wins 4 of 5 categories — our overall pick
Realme P1 5G is the overall winner, 4 / 5 — price is its standout. It costs USD 189 — USD 100 more than the Redmi A3. Pay the premium if price is your priority.
- Realme P1 5G takes Performance — led by ram (8 GB).
- Realme P1 5G takes Display — led by refresh rate (120 Hz).
- Realme P1 5G takes Camera — led by selfie camera (16 MP).
- Realme P1 5G takes Battery — led by charging speed (45 W).
- Too close to call between Redmi A3 and Realme P1 5G.
Scores follow our published methodology · v2026.09
In plain English
Choose Redmi A3 if you want…
- Choose Redmi A3 if you want a bigger screen — 6.71 in vs 6.67 in.
Choose Realme P1 5G if you want…
- Choose Realme P1 5G if you want a faster phone for apps and games — 600,000 pts vs 130,000 pts.
- Choose Realme P1 5G if you want more apps open at once — 8 GB vs 4 GB.
- Choose Realme P1 5G if you want a sharper screen — 395 ppi vs 268 ppi.
- Choose Realme P1 5G if you want smoother scrolling — 120 Hz vs 90 Hz.
- Choose Realme P1 5G if you want a screen you can read in sunlight — 1,200 nits vs 500 nits.
- Choose Realme P1 5G if you want sharper selfies — 16 MP vs 5 MP.
- Choose Realme P1 5G if you want a better camera — 86 pts vs 52 pts.
- Choose Realme P1 5G if you want faster charging — 45 W vs 10 W.
At a glance
- Redmi A3
- Realme P1 5G
Click a label to jump to that section ↓
Best price now
The cheap alternative
Full record
Every spec, side by side — winners get a check and a proportional bar. Ties share the badge.
Performance score
Approximate benchmark score of the chipset — higher is faster for apps, games and AI.
Chipset
The processor inside — shown for reference, never decides a winner.
RAM
More RAM keeps more apps alive in the background.
Storage
Base onboard storage for photos, apps and media.
Screen size
Diagonal screen size — bigger is better for media, smaller is easier to hold.
Pixel density
Sharpness of the screen — above ~400 ppi looks crisp.
Refresh rate
How smooth scrolling and motion feel. 120 Hz is the modern standard.
Peak brightness
Peak brightness in sunlight — higher stays readable outdoors.
Main camera
Resolution of the primary rear camera — photo quality is judged by the Camera quality score, not megapixels.
Selfie camera
Resolution of the front camera.
Telephoto
A dedicated zoom lens for distant subjects without quality loss.
Video score
Composite video rating — stabilisation, 4K/8K support and colour.
Camera score
Composite camera quality from independent testing — how good the photos actually are.
Battery
Battery capacity — higher generally lasts longer.
Charging speed
Wired charging speed — higher refills faster.
Wireless charging
Whether the phone charges wirelessly.
Price
Typical MSRP in US dollars — lower is better value.
Which one should you buy?
Redmi A3
Choose Redmi A3 if price matters most. It costs USD 89, the lowest price in this group.
Realme P1 5G
Choose Realme P1 5G if price matters most — it wins the most categories overall. It costs USD 189.
Pros & cons
Redmi A3
- Very cheap
- 5,000 mAh battery
- 90 Hz display
- Very slow chip
- 8 MP camera is weak
- 10 W charging
Realme P1 5G
- 120 Hz AMOLED
- Dimensity 7050
- 45 W charging
- No ultrawide
- Plastic build
- No telephoto